If you love a crisp wing but hate paying prestige prices, NYX Epic Ink Liner is the brush-tip pen most people reach for. Here is how it actually performs on long, busy days and who will love it most.
Overview
NYX Epic Ink Liner is a slim, brush-tip liquid eyeliner pen available in Black and Brown that promises saturated color, flexible control, and water-resistant wear at a wallet-friendly price. It is widely referenced as a drugstore dupe for the iconic brush-tip liners that dominate the high-end aisle, with a very similar fine brush made of individual bristles rather than a felt tip. The formula flows freely, lays down a deep, even line, and dries to a satin-matte finish that does not look crunchy or dull on the eyelid.
In day-to-day use, the pen feels light in the hand with a balanced cap that clicks on securely. The brush tip is ultra fine yet flexible enough to hug the lash line and flick out wings without skipping. The black shade reads true black in one pass and reaches an inky intensity with a second layer. Brown gives a softer, everyday definition that suits light or mature features. NYX lists the product as a vegan formula, and the brand is cruelty free, which is a nice bonus for an affordable liner.
Price varies by retailer, but it generally lands in the low teens, which is a fraction of comparable prestige pens. The big question is whether it actually holds up to real life, including long workdays, humidity, hooded lids, watery eyes, and the occasional rub. After testing it across different eye shapes and skin types, here is what stood out.
Who it’s for
This liner will be a strong fit if you want a precise wing without the learning curve of a stiff felt tip. The brush bristles flex and taper, so you can float the line along your lashes with very light pressure and get crisp edges. If you love a saturated black cat eye, you will appreciate the rich pigment and the way the second coat amplifies depth without cracking. If you prefer softer definition, the Brown shade is flattering for daytime and pairs well with neutral shadows.
It also works well for hooded eyes as long as you let it set for a few seconds before fully opening your eyes. On oily lids, it holds up better over primer and a touch of powder. If your eyes water, it resists smearing through light tears, though persistent watering at the inner corner can cause breakdown that you can patch with a dab of shadow. Beginners can handle it, but very shaky hands may find a felt tip steadier at first. If you want an absolute ultra-matte finish, or you tend to press hard and flood the lash line, you may prefer a drier-flow formula.
How it feels and performs
Tip and flow. The brush uses fine bristles that come to a needle-like point, so you can trace between lashes, tightline just above them, or flick a feather-thin wing. The ink flow is on the wetter side compared with some prestige pens. That makes the first pass smooth and skip-free, but it also means you should apply with a light hand to avoid too much product pooling at the outer corner. A quick shake before use helps the pigment look even from the first stroke.
Finish and opacity. Black is intense, with full coverage in one pass that looks even bolder with a second layer. Brown reads medium-deep with a neutral undertone, not too warm or red. The finish is satin-matte. It is not glossy like vinyl, but it is also not completely flat. Under indoor lighting it looks softly matte and photographs well without creating a chalky cast.
Dry time. It sets in about 10 to 15 seconds. That window matters for hooded lids and monolids. If your crease touches the line before it sets, you can get a slight print. Two simple fixes help. Keep your gaze lowered or look down during those few seconds, and set the liner tail with a tap of matching powder shadow once dry.
Wear and transfer. On normal to combination lids, the line stays sharp for 10 to 12 hours, including the wing. On oily lids in hot weather, expect about 8 to 10 hours before the outer tail softens. Transfer is minimal after set, as long as the skin was prepped with primer or lightly powdered. If you skip prep on very oily skin, some shine can cause slipping at the outer corner by late afternoon.
Water and sweat resistance. It resists smearing through light sweat or a misty walk to the car. Running water alone does not dissolve it immediately, but vigorous rubbing while wet will wear it away. Tears focused at the inner corner can soften the line there after a few hours. A tiny gap at the very inner corner or sealing that area with shadow can help.
Flaking and cracking. Even with a second coat, it does not crack. That is a standout result for a budget liner. No visible flaking throughout the day, even on mobile lids with fine lines. If you lay down a very thick band of liner in one swipe, it can look slightly raised, so two thinner passes look cleaner.
Over eyeshadow. It glides smoothly over matte and satin shadows. Over chunky shimmer or glitter, any brush pen can skip. The wetter flow of Epic Ink helps it bridge sparkle without stuttering, but go slow and use short strokes. Priming and lightly setting your lid first gives the smoothest canvas.
Sensitivity and contacts. There is no strong fragrance, and the formula is comfortable on most eyes. As with any liquid liner, tightlining directly on the waterline is not recommended if you wear contacts. Removal with a gentle balm or bi-phase remover is fast and reduces tugging.
The dupe question. Compared with a well-known high-end brush pen, Epic Ink is slightly wetter, a touch more satin, and can lay down more product if you press hard. The high-end pen often has a drier flow and an ultra-matte look with a slower build, which some find a bit more foolproof against smudging from tears. In exchange, NYX delivers similar precision and depth for much less money. If your top priority is price-to-performance, Epic Ink is an excellent stand-in. If you need the absolute toughest tear resistance for all-day events, a drier-flow prestige option may outperform it by a small margin.
How to use for best results
- Prep your lids. Blot excess oil with a tissue, apply a thin eye primer, then dust a soft layer of translucent or skin-toned powder. This adds grip so the ink does not slide.
- Shake the pen 5 to 10 times. This redistributes pigment so your first stroke is rich and even.
- Wipe the tip lightly on a clean tissue before the first eye. This removes any excess ink bead and prevents flooding at the outer corner.
- Map your shape. With eyes open and looking straight ahead, place two or three small dots along the lash line and at the wing angle you want. Connect the dots with short strokes rather than trying to draw one long line.
- Flick the wing first. Draw a small line from the outer corner toward the tail of your brow, then connect the tip back to the lash line to form a small triangle. Fill it in with feather-light strokes.
- Keep the eye half closed until it sets. Give it 10 to 15 seconds so it dries before your crease touches it. If your lids are hooded, draw slightly above the fold so the wing shows when your eyes are open.
- Seal for extra insurance. Tap a tiny bit of matching powder shadow along the outer half of the liner, or mist a sponge with setting spray and press around the eye area to lock everything in place without disturbing the line.
- Correct cleanly. To fix a wobble, dip a pointed cotton swab in micellar water and erase from the outside in, or use a thin brush with a touch of concealer to sharpen edges.
- Store tip down. Cap the pen tightly until it clicks and stand it upright with the tip facing down. This keeps the brush saturated so it performs like new every time.
Pros and cons
- Pros
- Fine brush tip delivers precise lines and crisp wings with minimal pressure
- Rich pigment with one-coat coverage and no cracking on a second layer
- Satin-matte finish that looks smooth in daylight and photos
- Long wear that resists transfer on primed lids and holds through full workdays
- Water resistant enough for light sweat and misty weather
- Vegan formula from a cruelty free brand at an accessible price
- Widely available with both Black and Brown shades
- Cons
- Wetter flow can pool if you press hard or do not wipe the tip first
- Not fully matte, which matte purists may notice
- May soften at the inner corner if eyes water continuously
- Requires a brief set time, so hooded lids should allow a few seconds before blinking fully
- Brush tip can fray over time if you cap it carelessly or crush it against the lash line
Final verdict
NYX Epic Ink Liner lives up to its reputation as a drugstore dupe that actually holds up. The fine brush tip, true-black pigment, and flexible control make it easy to create everything from a whisper-thin lash line to a dramatic wing. It wears strongly through long days with minimal transfer when you prep your lids and allow the quick set. For the price, it is hard to beat, and for most people it delivers the same clean, defined look they expect from prestige pens.
Choose it if you want performance and precision on a budget, if you like a satin-matte finish, and if you prefer a brush tip that glides rather than a felt tip that grips. Skip it if you need a completely flat matte look, you have very watery eyes all day, or you tend to press hard and flood the lash line. For everyone else, this pen is the reliable, affordable workhorse that earns a permanent spot in the makeup bag.
See also
If you are navigating fine lines or texture, you may also appreciate our picks for smooth application in Best Eyeliner for Older Women That Doesn’t Tug and gentle definition in Best Soft Eyeliner for Mature Eyes That Won’t Smudge. For lids that crease easily, our transfer-resistant favorites are in Best Eyeliners for Hooded Eyes That Don’t Transfer.
To lock in your look, finish with a mist from Best Setting Sprays for All-Day Makeup (2025) and a light dusting from Best Setting Powders That Don’t Age You in Photos. Those two steps make any liquid liner, including Epic Ink, last longer and look smoother in real life and in pictures.
FAQ
Is NYX Epic Ink Liner truly waterproof for all-day wear?
It is water resistant and holds up through light sweat, mist, and brief tears. Running water alone will not melt it immediately, but rubbing while wet will break it down. For long, humid days, prep with primer and set the outer wing with a touch of powder shadow to boost staying power.
Will Epic Ink Liner transfer on hooded lids?
It can print if your crease touches it before it sets. Give it 10 to 15 seconds with eyes half closed, or look down until it dries. Drawing slightly above the fold and sealing the tail with powder reduces transfer and keeps the shape visible when your eyes are open.
How does Epic Ink Liner compare to high-end brush-tip liners?
Epic Ink has a slightly wetter flow and a satin-matte finish, which glides easily for a smooth first pass. Many prestige pens run a hair drier and more matte, which can resist tears a bit better but may need more strokes to reach full opacity. In practice, NYX delivers very similar precision and wear for a much lower price, especially if you prep the lid well.
Which shade should I choose, Black or Brown?
Pick Black for dramatic wings, high-contrast looks, and evening makeup. Choose Brown if you prefer softer daytime definition or have fair features and want a less stark line. Brown also pairs nicely with neutral shadow palettes and looks flattering on mature eyes.
How long does one pen last and how should I store it?
With daily use for a single thin line, expect 6 to 10 weeks before the flow starts to taper. Store it capped tightly and tip down so the brush stays saturated. Avoid pressing hard on the tip, and never pump the brush on your lid, since that can fray the bristles and flood the line with excess ink.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on our site.