
Sensitive skin does best with short ingredient lists, gentle humectants, and barrier helpers like ceramides and panthenol. The sweet spot is a serum that hydrates and soothes without fragrance, harsh alcohols, or strong acids. If redness is part of the picture, look for calmers such as niacinamide, beta-glucan, or brand-specific peptides made for reactivity.
Below, three standout serums cover most needs: a fast-acting soother for flare days, a simple daily hydrator that strengthens the barrier, and a repairing option for chronic redness. Each review explains who it suits, who should skip, and how to use with fewer “stingy” moments.
Disclosure: This guide may contain affiliate links. If you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission at no cost to you.
Heads up: Sensitive skin varies. Patch test first and introduce one new product at a time.
Quick Picks
- Best immediate soother: La Roche-Posay Toleriane Ultra Dermallergo Serum — lightweight, fragrance-free calming serum for reactive skin. Rating: 4.7/5
- Best everyday hydrator: Vichy Minéral 89 Hyaluronic Acid Serum — minimal INCI, cushions skin and layers with everything. Rating: 4.6/5
- Best for ongoing redness: Paula’s Choice Calm Repairing Serum — barrier-first formula with beta-glucan, allantoin, and soothing plant lipids. Rating: 4.6/5
At-a-Glance Table
Serum | Best for | Star ingredients | Texture |
---|---|---|---|
LRP Toleriane Ultra Dermallergo | Flares, stinging, reactivity | Neurosensine (dipeptide), glycerin, thermal water | Watery-light |
Vichy Minéral 89 | Daily dehydration, barrier support | 89% mineral water, hyaluronic acid, glycerin | Gel-serum |
Paula’s Choice Calm Repairing | Persistent redness, dryness | Beta-glucan, allantoin, ceramide-like lipids, licorice | Silky lotion-serum |
Ratings reflect our editorial synthesis of brand information and owner feedback.
Deep Dives
1) La Roche-Posay Toleriane Ultra Dermallergo Serum — Best immediate soother
Why it stands out: Made for reactive skin, this water-light serum uses neurosensine (a calming dipeptide), glycerin, and thermal spring water to reduce the tight, hot feeling many sensitive types report. Owners often mention less sting when layering moisturiser and SPF afterward.
Who it suits: Easily triggered skin, post-over-exfoliation rescue, fragrance-sensitive routines.
Who should skip: If your only issue is dehydration and you want cushiony hydration, Vichy Minéral 89 may feel nicer.
How to use: After cleansing, apply 2–3 drops on damp skin AM/PM, then moisturiser and mineral SPF. During a flare, keep the routine to cleanser → Dermallergo → bland moisturiser → mineral SPF.
Pros
- Very short, gentle INCI
- Layers with prescriptions (ask your derm)
- Pump bottle, no fragrance
Cons
- Light hydration; dry types still need a cream
Rating: 4.7/5
2) Vichy Minéral 89 Hyaluronic Acid Serum — Best everyday hydrator
Why it stands out: A minimalist HA + glycerin gel in 89% mineral water that consistently boosts hydration without perfume or sticky residue. It plays well with makeup and sunscreen and is a good first serum when you’re simplifying.
Who it suits: Dehydrated, tight-feeling skin that wants cushion without actives. Great under makeup.
Who should skip: If you want redness-specific calming, Paula’s Choice Calm Repairing targets that better.
How to use: Two pumps on damp skin after cleansing, before any cream. In very dry climates, seal with a ceramide moisturiser so HA doesn’t evaporate.
Pros
- Tiny INCI list, fragrance-free
- Sink-in feel, no piling under SPF/makeup
- Travel-friendly and widely available
Cons
- Pure hydration only (no redness actives)
- Glass bottle isn’t ideal for showers
Rating: 4.6/5
3) Paula’s Choice Calm Repairing Serum — Best for ongoing redness
Why it stands out: Built for sensitive, redness-prone skin with beta-glucan, allantoin, licorice extract, and barrier-supporting lipids. The silky lotion-serum texture comforts dry patches and helps foundation sit better over time.
Who it suits: Diffuse redness, easily flushed skin, and those who need more than water-light hydration.
Who should skip: Ultra-minimalists who only want 3–4 ingredients; use Vichy instead.
How to use: One pump after a hydrating toner/essence or straight after cleansing, then moisturiser. Pairs well with azelaic acid at night if your derm okays it.
Pros
- Calming and barrier support in one
- Fragrance-free, alcohol-free
- Makeup-friendly finish
Cons
- More ingredients than a minimalist HA gel
- Price is mid to premium
Rating: 4.6/5
How to choose (and what to avoid)
- You flare and sting easily: Start with LRP Dermallergo.
- You just need hydration that always plays nice: Vichy Minéral 89.
- You deal with chronic redness/dryness: Paula’s Choice Calm Repairing.
Avoid, at least at first: strong fragrances, denatured alcohol high in the INCI, high-strength acids, essential oils, and minty/cooling agents (menthol, eucalyptus). Introduce vitamin C or retinoids later, in low-irritation forms (MAP or THD-Ascorbate for C; retinal or low-dose retinol) once your barrier is calm.
Routine order for sensitive skin
AM: Gentle cleanse or rinse → Serum (pick one) → Ceramide moisturiser → Mineral SPF → Makeup
PM: Gentle cleanse → Serum → Moisturiser → Optional thin petrolatum on sore corners
FAQs
Can sensitive skin use vitamin C serums?
Yes, but start with gentler forms (MAP, SAP, or THD-Ascorbate) at low strengths and patch test. Introduce once your barrier is calm.
Should I avoid niacinamide?
Most tolerate 2–5% well and it can reduce the look of redness. A small minority tingle—patch test and go slow.
Is hyaluronic acid safe for sensitive skin?
Generally yes. Apply to damp skin and seal with a moisturiser so it holds water in rather than pulling it out.
Can I layer more than one serum?
You can, but with sensitive skin stick to one active at a time. More layers increase the chance of irritation.
Mineral or chemical sunscreen with sensitive skin?
Mineral (zinc oxide/titanium dioxide) is usually better tolerated. Use it daily—UV is a major trigger for sensitivity and redness.
See also
If redness is a big part of your sensitivity, start with our step-by-step routine in Best Skin Care for Rosacea. For makeup that sits smoothly over sensitive skin, pair your serum with a texture-friendly base from Best Primer for Mature Skin and a flexible foundation in Best Foundation for Mature Skin Over 60.
To brighten without caking, see crease-light picks in Best Concealer for Dark Circles, then lock it in with the picks in Best Setting Sprays. For quick application tweaks that flatter sensitive, textured skin, try Makeup Tricks for Older Women.