Tarte Shape Tape Concealer is the classic full coverage, brighten-and-lift concealer that people treat like an instant filter. It promises high coverage, a natural matte finish, and long wear that resists creasing. Owner feedback leans hard on three points: it erases dark circles in one swipe, it stays on through a full day, and it makes the face look more lifted in pictures. Stylist commentary keeps using it for events, photos, and long days because it holds up under bright lighting and heat.
It is not a soft, dewy, sheer skin tint. It is intense coverage. It will tell on you if your under eyes are dry. The good news is that there is a sister version called Shape Tape Ultra Creamy that keeps the coverage but adds moisture for dry or mature under eyes. So you can choose what fits your skin instead of forcing one formula to work for everybody.
Quick Verdict
Best for:
People who want serious under eye brightening, coverage for dark circles or redness, and long wear that does not slide by lunchtime. This is what you use when you need to actually hide something, not just blur it.
Skip if:
Your under eyes are already dry, crepey, or textured. Classic Shape Tape can grab onto that texture and look heavy by late afternoon. If that is you, Shape Tape Ultra Creamy is usually the better match because it is made to feel more hydrating and more forgiving on mature under eyes. Another option people like for daily wear over 40 is Maybelline Instant Age Rewind, which has softer coverage and tends to sit nicer in fine lines, even though it is not as full coverage.
Price band:
High for concealer. Shape Tape sits in prestige pricing, not drugstore pricing. You pay more up front, but you also use less product because the coverage is strong.
Bottom line:
Shape Tape is still the go to for full glam, long wear, and photos. If you want something lightweight and forgiving for school run mornings, this is not that. If you want to look rested, lifted, and even in 30 seconds, this is exactly that.
Specs at a Glance
- Format: Liquid concealer with a jumbo doe foot wand
- Coverage: Full
- Finish: Natural matte, not dewy
- Wear: Long wear, marketed as crease resistant for hours and stays put through a normal work day
- Skin type target: Normal, combo, and oily under eyes get the smoothest result with the original Shape Tape
- Shade range: Dozens of shades across fair through deep, including different undertones
- Cruelty status: Marketed as vegan, cruelty free, and dermatologist tested
What that means in real life: this is a high coverage matte-leaning concealer in a big wand that is built for erasing and shaping, not just lightly brightening.
Ratings reflect a summary of owner feedback and stylist commentary.
Why We Picked It
For a lot of people, Shape Tape replaced foundation. Owners keep saying the same thing. One dot in the inner corner, one dot at the outer corner, blend upward, and you suddenly look awake. You do not need to color correct first. You do not need to layer it three times. That fast turnaround is why people stay loyal, even with the higher price.
Makeup artists keep it in wedding kits, event kits, and photo kits because it photographs well. The finish is natural matte, not shiny, so it does not bounce light in a weird way on camera. It also stays where you put it, so you are not babysitting it in the middle of the day.
The other reason it keeps winning is control. You can erase dark circles, cover redness around the nose, and tap it on a breakout, all with the same wand. A lot of buyers are using it like a pinpoint foundation instead of wearing a full face.
Performance Deep Dive
Under eyes with darkness
Shape Tape is known for pigment load. Translation: it is strong enough to cancel purple-blue under eye circles without having to use an extra corrector underneath. When you place it only where you are dark, and blend upward toward the outer corner, you get that bright lifted look people post in before-and-afters. On smoother under eyes, it can honestly look airbrushed.
If your under eye area is already dry, thin, or creased, the same formula can read heavy or chalky by late afternoon. That is usually where people switch to Shape Tape Ultra Creamy. Ultra Creamy is sold as the more moisturizing version for dry or mature under eyes, and that tracks with how people talk about it. Same coverage, kinder texture.
Redness and spot concealing
Because Shape Tape sets pretty quickly and grips, a tiny tap will cover redness around the nose, chin, or a breakout and stay there. You do not have to apply full foundation everywhere. You can literally dot, wait a couple seconds, and tap the edges so it blends into your skin.
Face lift trick
This is the concealer behind that upward swipe trick you see online. One short line from the outer corner of the eye up toward the temple and one short line at the corner of the mouth up toward the cheekbone, then blend, and your face looks more lifted. Matte plus brightness sells that illusion. Shape Tape leans matte and bright, so it works for that style.
All day wear
On normal to combo skin, Shape Tape tends to stay put through work, errands, and evening without melting off or turning shiny. On oilier T-zones, shine will come through, but the coverage is usually still there. On drier under eyes, people say it can start to look a little dry later in the day. That is where prep matters.
Wear / Result Timeline
First swipe
Coverage is instant. Your dark circle looks neutralized. Redness disappears. You look more rested and more lifted in under a minute.
After blending
It sets fast. The finish is already natural matte, so a lot of people do not even powder the under eye. That is rare with high coverage concealer.
Midday
Most users say it is still holding, still bright, and not sliding around. If you are combo or oily, you might blot shine in the T-zone, but you are usually not redoing the concealer.
Late afternoon
If you are already dry under the eyes or you have fine lines, you may see it start to emphasize texture. This is where mature users tend to either prep with eye cream under it, thin it out with a tiny bit of moisturizer, or just move to Ultra Creamy for daily use.
How to Use
Under eyes
Do not paint a giant triangle like the old tutorials. Instead, place a small dot at the inner corner and a small dot at the outer third of the under eye. Blend upward and slightly out with a damp sponge or fingertip. Keeping the product high and tight gives that lifted look without creating a big pale patch down the cheek.
Spot concealing
Tap a pinpoint amount on redness or a blemish. Let it sit for a few seconds so it starts to thicken and grab. Then tap the edges to blend. Do not blend it all the way out, or you will erase your coverage.
If you are dry or over 40
Press a thin layer of lightweight eye cream or hydrating primer under the eye first and let it sit for a minute. Then apply Shape Tape only where you need brightening. Less product on thin skin almost always looks younger than more.
Keep In Mind
Shape Tape is not automatically gentle. It is a high coverage, matte leaning concealer. That is why it lasts and why it photographs clean. It is also why some people say it looks dry on them by afternoon.
If you are already seeing fine lines under the eye, or if your skin there is thin from age or retinol, jumping straight into full coverage matte concealer with no prep can make those lines louder, not softer. This is the main reason Shape Tape Ultra Creamy exists. Ultra Creamy is sold as the same coverage with a more moisturizing, eye cream style feel for dry or mature under eyes.
You also have to respect the dry down. Shape Tape sets quickly. If you stripe it all over your face and then go hunting for a sponge, you will have trouble blending it. Tiny placement plus fast blending gives you a better result than packing it on.
Finally, price. This is not drugstore. You are paying prestige money for payoff, grip, and shade range.
Who It’s For vs Who Should Skip
Who it’s for
- You want your dark circles gone, not just softened
- You like a bright, lifted under eye look in photos
- Your skin is normal, combo, or slightly oily and can handle a natural matte finish
- You want one product that can do under eyes, redness, and spot concealing and last the whole day
Who should skip or test carefully
- Your under eyes are dry, thin, or already have visible lines when your face is resting
- You prefer sheer, dewy, almost-skin coverage instead of full glam
- You are on a strict drugstore budget
- You already know you crease hard with concealer unless it is hydrating. In that case, Ultra Creamy or a brightening concealer made for mature under eyes will be easier to live with every day
Owner Feedback Snapshot
What people love
- Covers dark circles in one swipe
- Makes the face look more lifted and awake fast
- Stays in place through work or events without constant touch ups
- Can double as contour and highlight by buying deeper and lighter shades
- Shade range is wide enough that a lot of people can get an actual undertone match instead of guessing
What people complain about
- Can look dry or heavy under the eyes later in the day, especially over 35
- Sets fast, so if you overdo it you can get a thick patch you have to fight with
- Price can feel steep for every single day use
Alternatives and Comparisons
Shape Tape Ultra Creamy Concealer
This is the sister formula for dry and mature under eyes. It keeps the full coverage and brightening, but it feels more cushioned and is marketed as hydrating long term. If classic Shape Tape looks crackly or pulls into fine lines on you, Ultra Creamy is usually the fix. Think same result, nicer texture on thinner skin.
Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Concealer
This is the common drugstore alternative people grab for a softer everyday look. Coverage is more medium brightening than full erase, but the texture tends to sit nicer on fine lines and not shout texture in daylight. It is also more budget friendly. The tradeoff is that it will not carve that super sharp lifted highlight the way Shape Tape does.
Pros
- Full coverage that cancels dark circles and redness fast
- Long wear and crease resistance for a full work day
- Natural matte finish that photographs clean and lifted
- Can replace foundation for quick face shaping
- Wide shade range with multiple undertones across fair through deep
- Vegan and cruelty free, according to brand marketing
Cons
- Can emphasize dryness or fine lines on mature under eyes
- Sets fast, so you have to blend quickly and use less
- Prestige price
- Matte leaning finish can look like makeup, not skin, if you prefer sheer glow
- Not the most forgiving daily choice for thin, crepey under eyes unless you prep or switch to Ultra Creamy
Final Thoughts
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer is still a power product. You buy it when you want dark circles gone, redness covered, and a lifted under eye that stays bright through the whole day. You can also use it to spot conceal and skip foundation completely. It is not soft and dewy. It is not trying to look invisible. It is trying to make you look awake, smooth, and more sculpted.
If you are in your 20s, 30s, or early 40s with normal to combo skin and you like that snatched, bright under eye style, Shape Tape still delivers. If you are already fighting dryness, creasing, or papery texture under the eyes, go straight to Ultra Creamy or a more forgiving brightening concealer that moves with the skin instead of locking down.
See also
If heavy concealer keeps making you look more tired instead of younger, our Over 40 Makeup Routine That Lifts Without Caking walks through placement tricks that brighten the face without packing product into fine lines. If under eye darkness is your main battle and you’re not sure if you need full coverage or just the right undertone, read Best Concealer for Dark Circles to line up finish, coverage level, and age concerns.
A lot of “cakey concealer” is actually dehydration under the eyes, not a bad formula. Dehydrated vs Dry vs Oily-Dehydrated: How to Tell at Home helps you figure out if you’re low on water, low on oil, or both, which changes how Shape Tape sits. If you run sensitive and certain products sting or go red around the eyes, our Fragrance-Free Makeup Kit for Sensitive Skin is built to keep the look polished without flare ups. After application, the set step matters, and over-setting is where a lot of people age themselves. Setting Powder vs Setting Spray: What to Pick shows when you should tap on a tiny bit of powder and when a light mist is kinder to fine lines.
FAQs
- Is Tarte Shape Tape Concealer good for mature under eyes?
Sometimes. On smoother under eyes it can look bright, lifted, and clean. On dry or crepey under eyes it can read heavy and accent texture by late afternoon. That is why Shape Tape Ultra Creamy exists. Ultra Creamy keeps the coverage but feels more moisturizing and is easier on mature skin. - Does Shape Tape really last all day without creasing?
On normal, combo, and slightly oily skin, most people say yes. It sets down, grips, and holds coverage through a standard work day. On drier under eyes, you may still see settling or dryness later in the day unless you prep with moisture first. - Do I have to set Shape Tape with powder?
Not always. Shape Tape dries to a natural matte finish on its own. If you are oily or you crease fast, you can tap a tiny bit of powder right where you fold. If you are dry or over 40, too much powder can make the area look older, so a light setting spray can be a better move. - Is it worth the price if I already have a drugstore concealer?
It depends on what you want. Shape Tape gives full coverage in one dot and holds for hours. Drugstore options can be more forgiving and cheaper for daily use, but usually give softer, medium coverage. If you want heavy lift and max brightening, Shape Tape still wins that lane. - How do I pick my Shape Tape shade?
Most people end up with two shades. One that matches their skin tone for redness and blemishes, and one that is slightly lighter for under eye brightening and that lifted effect. The range includes a lot of undertones across fair to deep skin, so you can usually find something that does not go gray or orange on you.
Affiliate Disclosure
If you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
